Horgan Government Urged to Act in BC's Best Interest and Scrap CBA
Victoria, BC—Construction workers from across British Columbia came together with contractors at the BC legislature today to call on the Horgan government to do the right thing and scrap its so-called community benefits agreements (CBAs) before any further damage is done.
“This government has all the evidence it needs to come to its senses and conclude its restrictive CBA is a costly mistake for all British Columbians,” says Ryan Bruce, CLAC BC manager of government relations. “It tramples on workers’ rights, jacks up the cost of taxpayer-funded infrastructure projects, and is driving away good contractors. The big question is, why carry on with such a lousy deal?”
BC’s rules for building public infrastructure fall short on every count. Horgan’s deal with his union buddies excludes 85 percent of the province’s construction workforce who do not choose to join the Building Trades Unions. It also hurts taxpayers. By the government’s own admission, its restrictive CBA will add $100 million to the cost of the Pattullo Bridge replacement project. The cost of four-laning a small section of the Trans-Canada Highway—another restrictive CBA project—has already escalated by more than $22 million.
“Sadly, our warnings a year ago of higher public costs have come true,” says Paul de Jong, president of the Progressive Contractors Association of Canada (PCA). “Another unfortunate reality is that government red tape and restrictive hiring rules are discouraging many highly qualified companies from bidding on public projects.”
For example, the Trans-Canada Highway widening at Kicking Horse Canyon (phase one) attracted only four bidders. A project of this scope would ordinarily attract 15 to 20 bidders. With fewer bidders, there’s less competition and costs go up. When public tax dollars are squandered in this way, there’s less funding for other needed projects, from hospitals and schools to transit.
“The vast majority of BC’s construction workers would have to change their union membership and put their pension and benefits packages on hold to work on public projects,” says Dawn Rebelo, equipment operator and member of CLAC Local 68. “That isn't right, and it sure isn’t constitutional for a government to treat workers so unfairly.”
PCA and CLAC are joined by other leading industry associations, which include the Independent Contractors and Business Association, Vancouver Regional Construction Association, BC Construction Association, Canadian Federation of Independent Business, BC Chamber of Commerce, and several employers and workers in a Supreme Court challenge of Horgan's restrictive CBA model. The case is to be heard on February 3-7, 2020.